Apna Loan  |  Apna Insurance  |  Apna Investment


Archive | Investment

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

GOLD ETF – How to buy and from where?

Posted on 13 April 2010 by Balwant Jain

My article last week in the DNA Money (Ref: Get your gold over time via a SIP dated 7th April, 2010) evoked keen response amidst readers who wanted to know the process of investing in SIP of gold ETF.

Not only this, many readers also wanted to know from where and how they can go about doing it. Indeed it speaks volumes about the love for gold we Indians have!

If you are one of those, I hope this piece of information will be of great help.

So for the beginners, it is a step-by-step process.

First and foremost you will need to open a Demat account with a depository participant before opening an account with a broker as brokers normally insist on opening a demat account before you can open a trading account with them. (In case you already have these then you can start right away after reading the article).

A Demat account is like a saving account of securities where you can electronically deposit or withdraw your shares like your money in savings account. When you buy any share, these are credited in your Demat account by your broker. There are broking Companies which provide Demat services also, therefore you can open the share trading account with one such brokerage houses. You can have more than one Demat account as well as share trading account.

For opening a Demat account, a valid PAN number and an Operative bank account is mandatory besides documents for your address proof like ration card, driving license, voter Id card, rent/purchase agreement in respect of the property or latest insurance policy status for a live insurance policy are required. You can also provide documents like electricity bill, bank statement, telephone bill or bank for the purpose.

In case your broker also offers Demat services known as Depositories Services, then both your Demat and share account are opened simultaneously.

However in case you have opened your demat account with depository like Stock Holding Corporation  Limited,  you need to open an account with a share broker, which is popularly known as trading account, for the purpose of buying the Gold ETF. The documents required for the purpose of opening the share trading account are almost the same as required for opening a Demat account.

Let me tell you that for buying or selling the Gold ETF units you do not have to open a new Demat or share trading account.

For purchasing and selling of Gold ETF you may call up your broker and place the order. Some brokers allow you to trade Online also.

The scrip name with underlying gold quantity and exchange code of major schemes of Gold ETF on Bombay Stock Exchange are given below as a ready reference for the people who buy stocks On line and for others to convey to their brokers what they want to buy specifically:

Name of the Mutual Fund Scrip name and BSE code

Underlying quantity in grams per unit

Benchmark Mutual Fund

Goldbees      590095

1.00

UTI Mutual Fund

Goldshare       590101

1.00

Quantum Mutual fund

Qgoldhalf      590099

0.50

Reliance Mutual Fund

Reliancegold     590100

1.00

Kotak Mutual fund

Kotakgold etf      590097

1.00

SBI Mutual Fund

Sbigoldets 590098

1.0

Except for the ETF of Quantum Mutual Fund which has a quantity of half gram against each unit all others have one gram of gold underlying each unit of Gold ETF.

These units are traded on stock exchanges and cannot be purchased from Mutual Funds. Here you cannot set up a SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) in its traditional way. But you can set the target of quantity of gold to be bought in a year and accordingly decide to buy the quantity spread over the year evenly. This will help you in absorbing the volatility in the price of gold.

Suppose you want to accumulate 10 gram of gold every month, you can plan to buy Gold ETF on alternate day of one unit or alternatively one unit of quantum for each day when the stock exchange is open as the market is on average open for 20 days in a month and if you buy 1 unit of quantum Gold Fund ETF on every day or 1unit of any other Gold ETF on every alternate day. Based on your target quantity of gold required in future, you can set the quantity and frequency of units to be purchased.

To give effect to the above plan, you can instruct your broker to buy the Gold ETF on the days fixed in advance. It will help if you set up your personal reminder for purchase of Gold ETF on fixed days. Some of the Online trading sites allow you to set up for auto purchase of shares. This arrangement will bring in financial discipline in those of who are careless about their money as they have to honor the cheques for payment of Gold ETF regularly and religiously.

As you are planning to purchase the Gold ETF on regular basis and the payment of money has to be made within three days normally, making of payment involves some logistics difficulty in arranging for payment frequently. In such cases where the payment of the purchase amount is automatically debited in the bank, like Online broking companies affiliated or floated by bank does not pose major logistics problem.

However in cases where the bank account and broking account is not linked, you can solve this difficulty by handing over a few cheques periodically. Do not forget to make the cheques for  not above a particular amount, which you think can be maximum  payable  in respect of purchase of Gold ETF during the relevant period. However please ensure that you maintain adequate balance in your bank account during currency of the self devised gold ETF.

So if you follow the SIP way, you can be a proud owner of gold over a period of time.

Comments (0)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Plan for your medical expenses after retirement NOW!

Posted on 02 April 2010 by admin

The high decibel advertising by the Life Insurance companies have already created a market of fairly conscious individuals who start planning for their retirement even when they are in the middle of their working lives. Also, the newly set up Pension Fund Regulatory Authority of India (PFRDA – which hopefully will soon become a statutory body) has done lot of work towards designing an excellent pension product, which is already being used by the Government and select PSU employees.

However, even among all this newly found (and welcome) consciousness on planning for retirement, we normally miss out on planning for medical expenses after retirement. I am sure each one of us will know somebody whose parent was hospitalized and was put on life support system for days together. Apart from the emotional stress caused by the hospitalization of a loved parent the overwhelming financial burden of such an illness (bills of Rs. 15 lacs to Rs. 20 lacs are not unheard of) has put several middle class families financial stressed for at least a decade or so.

All of us know that as we age, the need for medical attention and hospitalization increases. Advancement of medical technology has also ensured that we will live longer than our forefathers. But unfortunately it comes at a very high cost. Medical expenditure has been galloping at a rate much higher than the average inflation rate due to shortage of quality hospitalization infrastructure and use of sophisticated technology. Therefore planning for medical expenses after retirement is vital as it will be impossible (or too expensive) to get a policy after you retire.

So don’t try to dig a well only when you get thirsty. Individuals in their 30s or 40s today need to plan now for the medical expenditure after they retire. In fact the best planning can be done by individuals who are still healthy and without any pre-existing diseases.

So before setting out to plan your post retirement medical expenses, you should know the three kinds of risks that you need to cover:

  1. Your regular Mediclaim policy must not abandon you just when you need it the most.  So look at the maximum age up to which your current Mediclaim policy is renewable. As per the data available from the Apnapaisa Research Bureau only three companies offer policies that are renewable up to the lifetime - Apollo Munich Easy Health policies, United India Insurance - Mediclaim Policy Platinum and Oriental Insurance - Health Insurance. Additionally the following plans will renew the policy till 80 years of age.

Insurance companies Renewable till what age
Star Health – Medical Classic 80
National Insurance – Mediclaim 80
Reliance General – Individual Mediclaim 80
  1. As inflation rises your existing Mediclaim policies will become inadequate to handle the medical expenditure that arises after retirement. A mediclaim plan currently for Rs. 5 lacs may look adequate but this will become grossly inadequate after 15-20 years due to sheer rise in inflation and medical costs that have historically outstripped inflation by several multiples.

To cover for this risk you should go in for high deductible medical expenses reimbursement expenditure policies such as United India Insurance Super Top up policies. (See my write up in DNA of April 18, 2009). These will offer fairly high coverage of up to Rs. 15 lacs after deducting the first Rs. 3 - 5 lacs of hospitalization expenditure (which will get covered by your regular mediclaim policies). These plans are relatively cheap because of the high upfront deductible. In the current years these will help you cover against catastrophic medical expenses but as the years go by this policy (in combination with your regular mediclaim policy) will be just enough to cover your regular hospitalization expenses. Even here you must take polices that cover you when you need them the most – that is the age upto which the policy is renewable needs to be the highest. (Refer table below for details)

Insurance companies Renewable till what age
United India – Super Top Up Life time
Star Health – Super Surplus 75
Bajaj Allianz – Extra Care 80

For both 1 and 2 above it is better to pay a slightly higher annual premium today to get renewability till a higher age (as per IRDA guidelines insurance companies cannot deny renewal unless it is on the grounds of fraud, misrepresentation or moral hazard).

  1. You also need a cover for medical expenses that are not covered by either of these policies. Say for example, the amounts incurred for :

    1. Diagnostic tests (which regular policies normally cover only if they lead to hospitalization in 30 days) which are increasingly becoming very expensive,

    2. Treatment of chronic diseases such as lifelong medicines for organ transplants (not covered beyond 60-90 days after hospitalization) or

    3. Expensive implements (e.g. CPAP machines for obstructive sleep apnea)

It may be alright to leave these uncovered currently when you are still earning but after retirement it will become a big burden. A good way to plan for these expenses is through a separate nest egg for medical expenditure for yourself and spouse (your children should be planning this for themselves) through the regular route like diversified equity fund or an index fund. The target amount for this can be based on your current medical cover adjusted for inflation.

Some experts suggest using the Unit Linked Health Insurance Plans offered by Life Insurance companies for this purpose of creating a nest egg for such expenses, as you can utilize any left over tax deductions under section 80D (for payments made on Health Insurance covers) that may otherwise lapse. I, personally, do not recommend them due to the high costs associated with these plans including the high insurance costs that are deducted from the fund value which more than negate any tax advantage that contribution to these schemes may bring.

To summarize, plan now for your medical expenses in the old age and don’t let your retirement plan go awry.

Pointers:

  • Medical expenses after retirement can derail your retirement planning

  • Go for high deductible (top up and super top up) policies cover that will provide cover for catastrophic medical expenditure in current years and still is enough to cover regular hospitalization expenditure after retirement.

  • Use the regular method of SIP in a diversified equity fund or index fund to create a nest egg for your non-covered medical expenses.

Comments (0)

Tags: , , , , , ,

If it’s good, they will come and get it!

Posted on 19 February 2010 by Harsh Vardhan Roongta

The story is about a Public Sector Undertaking (PSU) which came up with an ultimate refrigerator. With its lowest market price, standard features and much lower power consumption, it was quite a buy. The Company appointed a dealer network which was experienced in selling consumer durables of other manufacturers. Now that Company was confident of its superior product backed by good dealer network, it did not feel the need for any advertising budget and paid peanuts as compensation to its dealers. But there was no manufacturer ‘warranty’ on the refrigerator.

The refrigerator was launched and now the time had come for the Company to take stock of sales after six months. The verdict was clear. Inspite of being a superior product, it was just not taking off. The customers were not even aware of the product. The dealers also made no attempt to sell the product to the customers who walked into their showrooms as they were not making any money. In fact, few customers who had read about the product in the newspapers, came asking for it were skilfully diverted to other competing products. Reason being - the dealers made more money on such competing products even though they were not as good.

Clearly the manufacturers dogma that if you make a good product consumers will come and get it had taken a beating here.

If we substitute this analogy with the Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA) for the – the PSU refrigerator manufacturer, Banks (Point of Purchase) for the dealers, the New Pension Scheme (NPS) for the new refrigerator and lack of guaranteed returns for the absence of warranty, you have the similar result.

Let’s analyse the scenario here in detail:

The high household savings rate in India has been much touted. Perhaps this drives the thought that the savers/investors have no choice but to channel a part of their savings in this otherwise excellent long term savings scheme – the National Pension Scheme. However, most Individual savers in India prefer traditional savings instruments such as land, gold and bank fixed deposits. One thing common among these instruments is that it requires one time investment with no obligations on making a regular contribution over time. In fact even here the relatively newer products such as PPF, NSC etc. which are safe and provide good returns also needed support from individual sales agents to make sure that the operational difficulties in investing in these products is taken care of.

This kind of investments naturally favours the relatively better off people since they would have the lump-sum available to invest. The whole concept of systematically saving and investing something over time to fulfil a financial goal requires discipline and commitment.

Considering this NPS is a good scheme and no doubt gives excellent results but it still is a tough sell especially if the return is not guaranteed. As a result such products need both – wide publicity as well as reasonable incentives for the selling. Unfortunately both are lacking in the otherwise excellent pension scheme. Thus perhaps leading to an excellent product, not ready to take off. (It is not just the current tax disadvantage that this product suffers vis-à-vis other savings products that is causing such low off take). Moreover the general awareness of the product itself is quite low.

Another potential future issue is the extremely low fund management charges paid to the fund managers. To give you an idea - if the fund house is managing Rs.10,000 Crores of funds, the total payout will be Rs. 9 lacs only which is not even enough to cover the salary cost of a single executive. Obviously either the managers hope to make some money in some other manner (brokerage etc. for their sister companies perhaps) or will perhaps loose interest in the business over time. Anyway this will become a problem only at a future date when the scheme becomes popular.

We hope that after the proposed tax changes take effect in 2011, we will also see changes in the selling structures and incentives for all the stakeholders in the NPS.

We wish that this unique scheme which can be a boon for Indian investors looking for long-term disciplined savings does not meet the same fate as that of mythical PSU Refrigerator manufacturer mentioned above.

Comments (0)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Easy get rich-retirement solutions tips for today’s young job professionals

Posted on 10 December 2009 by Bharat Parekh

Planning to get retired after getting rich is a dream of every person today engaged in earning a livelihood for achieving a sound financial and monetary base. Get rich retirement solutions have also gained prominence due to the fact that present day life is full of uncertainties like serious health disorders, unexpected accidents, even death that may leave family members of deceased retired person into financial crisis if he doesn’t create strong money and finance provisions for providing a happy and secure life to his family. Recently with development of Indian economy due to increase of foreign investments in Indian government as well as private sector youthful job professionals of India have seen salary increments and hikes. Along with meeting important requirements of life including basic necessities like housing, food and clothing today every youth is looking forward into the future for achieving maximum money savings and a secure financially rich retirement from his job at a very early phase. Tips given below may guide you select the best financial savings and investment plan:

  • Gain control on your financial expenses:

A simple life style enhances more money savings and enables you to invest your hard saved money into a high monetary return and long term retirement investment plan. Just take control on your hi-tech cash payment transactions. Devote your attention in simple yet easy daily routine pursuits like spending with your family and friends, simple hobbies like reading, writing, walking and traveling along outskirts of your city on a small picnic this won’t cost you too much.

  • Keeping your financial and retirement goals together:

Easy, early and rich retirement solutions require keeping your financial and retirement goals together. In the early years of your job you should plan your financial goals and devise ways to achieve it. Chalk out your individual as well as family expenses if your spouse is earning then you could frame a monthly family budget with combined income of yourself and your life partner. Then you should select a reliable income generating retirement plan after keeping current age human life expectancy as well as current inflation hikes.

  • Make your self inclined towards more money savings:

For selecting the best, reliable and get rich retirement plan you should avoid increasing your lifestyle expenses no matter your salary is increasing constantly. Each fraction of money saved is money gained. Financial experts dealing with life insurance, mutual funds, shares & equity including income generating retirement solutions suggest to devote 25% of monthly income in savings.

  • Start investing money early to double your money:

By investing money early you can double your money as after every 5-6 years rate of money returns on financial return also double. Whereas in loan plans and mortgage interest rates on money recovery increases.

  • Choose a long period retirement plan:

Choose a long period retirement plan or finance investment solution prepared with correct monetary logistics. For this purpose you could consult an experienced financial consultant at periodic intervals.

  • Try to create additional sources of income:

By creating additional sources of income you make your life easier from monetary point of view as it helps you to pay high amount monthly, half yearly or annual investment premiums on rich making retirement plans. For this purpose you should review your talents and explore part time job solutions that demand less investment of time daily. By following these simple tips you could enhance chances of get rich along with a secure retirement.

Comments (0)

Tags: , , , , ,

Buying leisure property? Don’t treat it as an investment!

Posted on 04 December 2009 by Harsh Vardhan Roongta

I was pleasantly surprised to receive a call from Raj Gupta, who has been a close friend since my CA days. But bigger surprise unfolded when he told me that he had won an argument with his wife for the first time in life,  all because of me!

He was very excited, thanked me profusely for my article in DNA. ( Refer my article on October 3 – Buy another home…)  I was even more surprised to note that my advice can make people win an argument with their wives. ( A thing that I have personally never been successful at).

 

Naturally my interest level in the conversation rose. I was keen to know the details. He explained that for last few months he has been arguing with his wife over buying ready made farm house-cum-plot near Karjat, approx. 100 Kms from Mumbai. His  wife has been opposing the plan, closing that it was a luxury that they could ill afford at this point of time.

 

And my above article extolling the virtues of buying a second home helped him in convincing his wife that it was not a luxury purchase but an investment he was making for their retirement.  Raj said, “See, even Harsh supports my view”.  Hence Raj was extremely happy with the article. 

 

Paradoxically I need to clear this illusion not only for Raj but for all of you who have stretched my advice a bit too far. What my article really suggests is that buying another house which is capable of being rented out.  It can be a good retirement planning tool. Moreover it should not be important that whether you would have yourself liked to stay in that house or treat it as weekend gateway. You should buy from a rental perspective. In fact buying a house in smaller towns that you have some knowledge and connection with, might be a great decision given the fast pace of growth that is likely to be experienced by smaller towns and might give good returns over a long period of 20 years.

 

But what Raj  was proposing is not in consonance with my suggestion, as a leisure property  could hardly be rented out on a continuous basis. Besides it is difficult to liquidate a leisure property as it cannot be sold easily thus becomes difficult to realize the value of such properties in India. Despite growing economy, FDI influx, rising urban incomes, reach of internet and many such factors, leisure property market is not very well developed in India. Moreover, there is lack of transparency at the operational level and so is the depth in such markets. Hence, getting resale value of a leisure property is very difficult, getting rental for the leisure property is even more difficult.

 

Let me add here that even the builders of such leisure properties have to rely on large marketing organization and marketing campaign to sell them and it is quite time and effort consuming process. This is not practical for an individual looking to sell his leisure property.

 

So should you never buy a leisure property? No, I am clearly not saying that, But it should not be bought, thinking it is a good investment. It should be bought from that part of your assets that are allocated to pay for luxury that most people are entitled to after achieving a certain earnings and savings status. Buying it under the mistaken notion that it is a great investment, could perhaps be a big financial mistake. In the event of any stress in your financial life, your ability to liquidate that leisure property quickly might be very difficult. But clearly all those of you who want to get away from all the distress around and connect with your families over the weekend, in a self-owned weekend gateways can positively impact your overall lifestyle and improve your earning potential. To that extent it can be considered to be well spent.

 

So I am not surprised that once again another wife has won the argument.

Alas! my friend Raj’s happiness was short lived. But then he, like most of us, is a good loser and gives in with grace when he knows he cannot win the argument.

Comments (0)

Tags: , , , ,

Your best retirement plan – Buy another house!

Posted on 06 October 2009 by Harsh Vardhan Roongta

Most people build a nest egg for their retirement by investing a regular sum of money into a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) of a mutual fund or buy a pension plan from an insurance company or regularly invest in a bank recurring deposit or government backed instruments such as PPF and NSC, etc. A very few well-informed consumers are also opting for the newly launched New Pension Scheme.

 

But there is another very effective means to build a sizeable pension corpus - Buying another residential house for the purpose of deriving rental income as well as long-term capital appreciation.

 

I will illustrate this with an example.

 

Mr. Prabhat Varma has ability to pay a down payment of Rs. 2 lacs and can service an EMI of Rs. 6,000 every month (in other words he is able to save Rs. 6,000 per month).

 

This means that he can invest in a house worth Rs. 11 lacs for which he will be able to get a loan of around Rs. 9 lacs. The EMI for this 20-year loan at 9% is around Rs. 8,100 per month, which Mr. Varma will easily be able to pay from the rental income (estimated at around Rs. 3,000 per month), clubbed  with the existing savings of Rs. 6,000 per month. The tax deduction on the home loan (for rental properties the tax deduction will continue even under the new Direct Tax code) and any potential increase in rent in later years is just an icing on the cake.

 

Even if we assume a rather conservative 10% p.a. capital appreciation the property will be worth Rs. 74 lacs at the end of 20 years. Thus the easy availability of home loans even for residential property bought for the express purpose of renting it out effectively turns this investment into a SIP into real estate. 

 

While Mr. Varma crystallises his plan for another house purchase, he should keep few of these things in mind:  

 

1)      This is not about the house that you are staying in, the house in question here is  purely for investment purpose. 

2)      An investment horizon of at least 10 years is needed for this to be effective,  so if you are planning to retire by 60, and then this is not for you if you are already above 50 years of age.

3)      This is much riskier than a bank fixed deposit (the expected returns obviously are higher to compensate for the higher risks) and so if your risk appetite is low then this investment is not for you

4)      A meaningful Real estate investment will require much larger initial investments as also much larger continuing investments. Also the flexibility to miss an regular investment instalment is not available since the continuing investment is by way of loan repayment.

5)      It is not important that whether you would have yourself liked to stay in that house or not. You should buy from a rental perspective. In fact buying a house in smaller towns that you have some knowledge and connection with, might be a great decision given the fast pace of growth that is likely to be experienced by smaller towns and might give good returns over a long period of 20 years.

6)      Investment in real estate is a relatively high maintenance investment in terms of dealing with societies, finding and dealing with tenants, etc.

7)      Though state and local laws are fast changing tenancy laws in some states and property taxes in some cities make renting out a property a non-viable option. So avoid investment in such areas.

 

 

So this investment proposition is ideal for the likes of Mr. Varma who like saving regularly in traditional assets such as real estate.

 

How about you? Are you like Mr. Varma?

Comments (0)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Chronicles of retail investor

Posted on 03 September 2009 by Krishna Ravi

My dad is notorious and conservative, when it comes to investing in the stock market. So yesterday was a new dawn for the financial planning for my family, when he ask me to check out some particular stocks to invest in. My dad’s ideology towards the share market is similar to any middle class individual. So how did this big leap happen? Are the middle class really participating in the capital markets in large numbers?

The coming of age for retail investor.

The Harshad Mehta scam created a huge dent in Indian share market’s reputation. My dad was even wary of the word “stock market” back then. I thought situation might change during the dot-com boom, when middle class investors lap up the high reputed stocks like Infosys, Wipro etc. But Stock market has uncanny habit of proving people wrong and I was proved wrong, when dot-com bust happen. Still there were many middle class investors at that point of time. This was the beginning of the emergence of retail investors.

The Bull run of 2003-2007 saw huge participation from the middle class. The Maruti IPO in 2003 (initial public offer) started the trend of block buster IPOs . It was as if someone has opened the floodgates for the middle class investors. The retail investors jump at the opportunity to invest their beloved brands like Maruti, ONGC(Oil and Natural Gas corporation), TCS(Tata Consultancy services), Reliance power, Reliance petroleum. These were trustworthy and reputed brands and retail investors were not at all hesitant to buy these shares. The year 2004 saw three massive IPOs and all of them were oversubscribed.

Year 2004  IPO size (in crores)

1. ONGC- 9500

2. TCS- 5420

3. NTPC - 5368

This mega IPO had a huge impact on the retail investors. The reluctant investors like my dad started taking  keen interest in the stock market. The retail investors made the bull run of 2000s their very own. Every individual can make money in any investment category, if he is vigilant enough. The article clearly signifies the coming age of retail investor and my dad of course in respect to stock market.

Comments (0)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Debt – A safe investment instrument

Posted on 04 August 2009 by Nausheen Khakiani

“Recession” today has struck everyone in some or the other way. India would not be affected by it in a significant way they say, however, it does have some impact on every individuals life. Things are getting better by the day. The stock market - which usually people believe is the benchmark and decides where the economy is really going, is also doing well from the past few months. This change in the stock market has come in only after the elections. Slowly, as the economy is showing some progress, importance of debt instruments are increasing.

In the month of February, Tata Capital NCD’s (Non - Convertible Debentures) which gave interest returns of around 12% p.a are now beneficial especially in this market. As a Daily Newspaper rightly suggested yesterday on the 29th of July 2009, that Experts have advised investors to stick to existing debt plans interest rates are likely to remain steady in the medium term. In its policy review meeting on Tuesday, RBI has not changed the reverse repo rate, repo rate or the bank rates for that matter. Hence clearly, interest rates can remain stable in the medium term at least.

Another expert advice for investors mentioned was to go in for corporate deposits which are likely to offer higher rate of return than the conventional bank fixed deposits. They are also generally backed strongly. For example, the Tata Capital Issue was backed by Tata Sons. The latest Shriram Transport Issue which has been oversubscribed more than eight times is now the talk of the town.

These debentures are usually tradable on the stock exchange and sometimes come with call/put options. Hence compared to a simple bank fixed deposit, these are quiet liquid. So one now has a safer investment option with guarantees returns and sometimes give nifty participations too.

Comments (0)

Tags: , ,

No entry load for Mutual Funds! A cause for celeberation?

Posted on 29 June 2009 by Harsh Vardhan Roongta

Assuming this decision is implemented (it is yet to be officially intimated to the mutual fund industry although the press release is dated June 18, 2009) I think it needs to be welcomed with a muted cheer. The reaons for a rather muted cheer are many.

The Mutual fund industry will now not be able to give any upfront commission (at least officially) to the mutual fund agents. The agents are expected to ask the investor to pay separately for the services rendered. Off course they will still be entitled to the commission that most mutual funds pay when the investor continues to keep his money in the scheme (called trail commission ).  This has already caused a lot of discomfort to the mutual fund distributors and they are reportedly organising a dharna at the SEBI offices in Mumbai even as i write this blog.

So then is this a good thing for the individual investor? In my opinion this is a mixed blessing for the investor. First assuming this applies to NFOs as well (not very clear to me right now) the rush of new NFOs that will die down and we will see the consolidation of various schemes.  The biggest advanatge off course is that the investors will now be able to negotiate the amount of fees that they wish to pay to their agent and pay him directly at the time of purchase.

Having said that follows some of the disadvanatges of this step if implemented :

The charge structure for the mutual fund industry is expected to change significantly and we are likely to see singinificant increases in trail commissions. This charge  is debited to the scheme account and reduces the NAV. In fact a high trail commission which is payable on the portfolio value (inlcuding the gains that the portfolio has made) and not just on the amount contributed by the consumer will ,for an investment held over 8-10 years, result in a lower investment value for the consumer.  We have done a very interesting excel calculation. We took the example of a systematic Investment plan for Rs. 10,000 per month for a period of 15 years. If you took the average annual returns at 12% p.a. and the entry load at 2.25% the cumulative value of the investment before considering any trail commission is around Rs.48,83,000. If we remove the entry load of 2.25% and substitute it for a trail commission of 0.40% p.a. the investor will accumlate only around Rs. 48,10,000 at the end of 15 years i.e. he would have been better off with the entry load of 2.25% rather than an increase in trail commission by 0.40%. The reason for these startling numbers is not difficult to find - whereas the entry load is charged only on the incremental amount invested the trail commission is charged on  the entire cumulative investment amount including the returns that the investors are entitled to.

If we extend the same example but take only a period of 10 years then the investor would be more or less the same in both the alternatives. If we take an even smaller period of 5 years the investor would be better off paying an extra  trail commission of 0.40% rather than an entry load of 2.25%. Thus clearly an extra trail commission in lieu of an entry load discriminates against a long term regular investor.

The other big issue is that with the entry level commissions reducing so significantly the distributors may shift to promoting only ULIP products which may not be suitable for all consumers.

However it is reported that AMFI has made a representation to SEBI to defer the implementation of this  desicion. Meanwhile IRDA is also reportedly planning to issue guidelines for streamlining all charges in a ULIP plan and is even reportedly considering a  maximum limit for such charges.

All in all this is one domain where we are likely to see lots of changes in the next few months. The manner in which financial products are distributed in India is going to completely change. Keep watching this space…….

Comments (0)

Tags: , , , , ,

MF sold without my permission

Posted on 29 June 2009 by Subhasis.M

Dear Sir/Madam,

Can you kindly advise me how to and where to register my complaint for the following?

My stock broking agent has sold out my MF holdings HSBC dynamic growth on 3/6/9 without my consent.I asked for the compensation but they declined.

How can I proceed?

If the NAV is down from the selling NAV then is there any point pursuing this matter?

kindly advise

Subhasis

Comments (0)

Advertise Here

Advertise Here
  • CALENDAR

      September 2010
      M T W T F S S
      « Aug    
       12345
      6789101112
      13141516171819
      20212223242526
      27282930  


Disclaimer

The Apnapaisa Blog specifically disclaims any responsibility for any loss, actual or consequential, caused due to any decisions taken on the basis of any material appearing on the blog. Please consult your personal finance advisor, insurance agent, or broker before taking any decision to buy any financial product.